6/6 AP English Language Argument Essay: Jemison on advice
This is a real argument essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 6/6 by our AI grader — one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
In the 2009 keynote address for the Annual Biomedical Research Conference for Minority Students, physician, engineer, and former astronaut Mae Jemison—the first African American woman in space—stated: “Never be limited by other people’s limited imaginations. If you adopt their attitudes, then the possibility won’t exist because you’ll have already shut it out.... You can hear other people’s wisdom, but you’ve got to re-evaluate the world for yourself.” Write an essay that argues your position on the extent to which Jemison’s claim about considering others’ opinions is valid. In your response you should do the following:
- Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position.
- Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning.
- Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
- Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
The Essay
Mae Jemison was the first African American woman in space, an astronaut, physician, and engineer. At the 2009 Annual Biomedical Research Conference for Minority Students, she presented to a group of minority students, eager to dive deeper into their interests. She speaks to help motivate the minority students to pursue their dreams despite others’ opinions. Mae Jemison’s position on choosing your own world, preserving through challenges, and pursuing your own ambitions is valid, even if some may say it is important to take others’ opinions. Many people tend to take others’ opinions to heart, and immediately shut out their own ideas. However, it is important to make your own decisions individually. The Beatles, one of the most influential music groups, had originally been rejected by the first record company they auditioned for. Despite the company’s uncertainty with their music, they still chose to pursue other opportunities with different record companies. The Beatles ended up becoming one of the most well known music groups, changing the music industry forever. Jemison states how you should, “Never be limited by other people’s limited imaginations” (Jemison). Instead of taking the first rejection as a dead end, the Beatles chose to still pursue other opportunities. This is what helped them gain their eventual success. It is important to have confidence in your own judgment, and consider others’ opinions while still making your own decisions. It is important to continue with your ideas, even when the situation may push you down. For example, the e-commerce company Amazon originally started as a small online bookstore that faced losses in its beginning. However, Jeff Bezos, the founder of present-day Amazon, persevered through the challenges and let his own imagination lead the way. His decision to expand Amazon from just a bookstore is what kickstarted the success. He chose his own imagination, instead of constricting himself and his ideas purely based on external issues. Amazon is now the internationally largest e-commerce platform, has a loyal customer base, and is a multi-trillion dollar company. Rather than being discouraged, he pushed out of the difficult times. Jemison mentions how “you’ve got to re-evaluate the world for yourself” (Jemison). This emphasizes how you should not let others' ideas limit your imagination, and instead choose your own future. When you let others' inside-the-box thinking affect you, you suppress your potential and vision. There are many examples of people choosing their own future, such as Steve Jobs who went above technology standards with Apple’s technology innovations, Malala Yousafzai through advocating for women's education, the creators of Poppi, a probiotic soda company pursued their unconventional idea even after facing lots of criticism on Shark Tank. The similarity with all of these people is that they all did not conform to society’s thinking, and rather chose their own path. While it is crucial to make your own decisions, others’ opinions can be valuable to an extent. Other opinions are still worth listening to, as they provide a different perspective. This other perspective comes from experiences that you may not have lived. For example, the Youtuber MrBeast is someone who fully built his engagement over time. He considered all the aspects of videos that the viewers had the best engagement with, and improved his own videos. Instead of taking poor engagement as a sign to stop, he viewed it as an area of improvement. He used this data from all of his videos to strengthen his own videos and creativity. The viewer data helped him understand where he needs to improve, and he took this by adjusting the way he makes videos. However, it is important to note that these suggestions should not fully change how you originally wanted it to be. Jemison emphasizes how “You can hear other people’s wisdom” (Jemison), but you still have to evaluate the situation on your own. While small changes may be helpful, you should still be the one making major decisions. I agree with Mae Jemison’s ideas on never limiting yourself based on surroundings, and choosing your own destiny. Overall, it is important to understand that at the end of the day it will only be you, your imagination, your creativity, and your ambition. Other people will come and go, but your ideas and imagination stay. Therefore, it is crucial to recognize the difference between accepting helpful criticism, and letting others shut down your dreams. Listening to others’ advice can help you grow, but you must keep the confidence to stay in the path that you choose for yourself.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Evidence & Commentary (4/4)
Sophistication (1/1)
Why This Essay Scored Well
The thesis takes a qualified side. It calls Jemison's position valid "even if some may say it is important to take others' opinions," and the final body paragraph returns to that qualification. The writer grants that other views "provide a different perspective" drawn from "experiences that you may not have lived," which explains why advice deserves a hearing at all.
Each main example ends with commentary tied to a line from Jemison. The Beatles paragraph describes the first record company's rejection, explains that the band refused to read it as "a dead end," and says this choice "is what helped them gain their eventual success." The Amazon paragraph shows Bezos pushing past a money-losing online bookstore and connects that choice to Jemison's call to "re-evaluate the world for yourself." Across both paragraphs, the essay pairs a story with the quoted claim it supports.
The sophistication point comes from the MrBeast paragraph. The writer treats viewer engagement data as a kind of outside opinion worth using, describing how MrBeast "viewed it as an area of improvement." The paragraph then draws a limit, that "small changes may be helpful" while major decisions stay with the creator. That boundary turns a simple claim about ignoring critics into a position about which kind of input to accept.
For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.
What Could Be Improved
The end of the Amazon paragraph lists Steve Jobs, Malala Yousafzai and the founders of Poppi in a single sentence with no commentary. A reader learns that these people exist but not what choice each one made or why it proves the claim. One of them, explained in two sentences, would carry more weight than all three named.
Commentary in the Beatles and Amazon paragraphs often restates the conclusion in general terms. The Amazon paragraph says Bezos "let his own imagination lead the way" but never names whose limited imagination he ignored, so the link to Jemison's warning about other people's views stays loose. The introduction also spends three sentences on Jemison's background before the thesis arrives, and the thesis writes "preserving" where it means persevering.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang argument essay



