6/6 AP English Language Argument Essay: DeGrandpre on planning
This is a real argument essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 6/6 by our AI grader — one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
In a book published in 1999, psychologist Richard DeGrandpre asserts: When we ruminate about and plan things to come, when we study and work toward some anticipated eventuality, and when we imagine and harbor certain expectations about what the future could, should, or will be like, what we are often doing, albeit unintentionally, is redirecting our consciousness away from the present and into the future. When we do this, there is a tendency, again unintentional, of undervaluing our sense of the present. How does thinking about the future affect one’s ability to experience and appreciate the present? Write an essay that argues your position on the extent to which anticipating and planning for the future affects our capacity to, as DeGrandpre puts it earlier in the same chapter, “appreciate the moment and, ultimately, life as a whole.” In your response you should do the following:
- Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position.
- Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning.
- Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
- Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
The Essay
In the age of toxic productivity, where Pinterest boards, Instagram posts, as well as Youtube videos, romanticize long hours of studying, endless to-do lists, and prestige, countless pressure amounts on students, workers, and even parents—everyone—to make detailed plans about their lives, and to live life to its fullest. People respond to this productivity trend differently: while some decide to map out their lives in detail, others intend to go with the flow, resonating with the saying, “living in the moment.” Since appreciating the moment suggests enjoying the simple joys and privileges in life, such as sunshine, nature, interactions with family and friends, some may argue that thinking about the future may redirect one’s attention from the present to the future, thus stealing one’s sense of the present. However, without a proper schedule and detailed plan, one could succumb to laziness, engaging in meaningless activities that do not contribute to the betterment of the world or themselves. The key to living life fully actually lies in finding the middle ground between enjoying the moment and working towards one’s goals–being able to enjoy life while living a purpose-driven life–and making detailed plans allows just that. While some opponents may argue that thinking about the future may hinder one from appreciating the moment, making visionary plans allows individuals to live with a purpose by enabling them to find a work-life balance instead of aimlessly wandering. Planning for the future allows people to live with a sense of meaning. In fact, many of the most successful people think about and plan for the future regularly. Jesus, during his life on earth, did not focus on healing the sick or saving the Israelites from the Romans’ rule. Instead, with his ultimate purpose in mind—to sacrifice on the cross to save humanity from sin—regularly forewarned his disciples of his death and centered his ministry around spreading the good news to more people. Jesus understood his purpose on earth, so he did not aimlessly do what he wanted. Similarly, Elon Musk, the founder of Tesla, has always held a clear sense of futuristic goals in mind. As a result, he quit his investment in certain realms that thwarted his goals–including pursuing a higher education. Musk considered the big-picture of his life: while many may chase prestige and view his decision to drop out of college as reckless, Musk knew he wanted greater accomplishments than merely earning a college diploma. Thus, he built his Space X company, making a meaningful impact worldwide. Both Jesus from the Bible and Elon Musk are a testament that planning for the future allows one to live life with a future instead of dabbling in activities aimlessly but making no progress. In addition to providing a sense of meaning, plans for the future enables one to find a work-life balance. By planning ahead, one may have more free time to engage in exploring new obsessions and hobbies. Three years ago, before learning how to make to-do lists and a weekly schedule, I, as a student, struggled with time management as I faced a constant temptation to procrastinate before completing my homework. However, as I started planning for my day, as well as making more ambitious annual and weekly plans, I not only recognized the value of thinking about the future but also how planning sets my heart at ease. Thanks to my daily schedule and weekly plans, aside from completing my daily tasks on time, I can have more freedom to invest in my hobbies–something I could never have done without a detailed and futuristic plan. My individual case applies to other students who may be wrestling with time management since planning for the future is actually scientifically supported to maximize one’s productivity. Since the emotional-regulating part of the brain, the amygdala, may act upon impulses and succumb to laziness when one does not have a clear plan for the day. Working against the amygdala, making a detailed plan engages the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain that controls decision-making and planning. Consequently, planning allows the prefrontal cortex to overdrive the emotions of the amygdala, not only reducing decision fatigue, which describes the phenomenon where one has an overwhelming number of options of what to do to choose from, but also helps one to prioritize important tasks first before relaxing. Consequently, planning for the future is a way to maximize the amount of time one has: planning allows one to take breaks from working after one completes their daily tasks punctually, thus helping individuals to find the sweet spot between working productively and appreciating the present. While planning for the future comes with various benefits, simply having a futuristic plan and mindset does not factor in the unpredictability of life. Since accidents take place every day, and one has to adjust to changes when their plans are thwarted by unexpected events, critics may argue that making plans cannot prepare one for the future. However, having detailed plans allows one to face the volatility of life more with ease than having no plan at all: while adjusting to changes may be challenging, repeatedly making new plans allows for growth and helps one budget space for unpredictability. Planning helps prepare individuals to adapt to changes: individuals can learn to schedule buffer time blocks to complete tasks or goals left unfinished due to unpredicted accidents. Ultimately, alongside providing a work-life balance, planning for the future allows one to live with a meaning–benefits that simply going with the flow of life does not provide. Since everyone has limited time on earth–witht he luckiest people perhaps living up to late 90s, individuals should become stewards of their time by taking the first step: thinking about and planning for the future. While uncertainties are inevitable, planning prepares one to better adjust to changes and prepare for the future. Although morbid, the question, “what do you want people to say in the eulogy given in your funeral” exemplifies the value of planning in living life to its fullest potential. Planning allows one to take advantage of one’s resources–including financially and relationally—by trying to make the most uncontrollable asset in life, time, somewhat controllable. By scheduling time for both relaxation and working toward one’s ambitious goals, one can maximize their limited time and contribute to society by accomplishing meaningful things through planning.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Evidence & Commentary (4/4)
Sophistication (1/1)
Why This Essay Scored Well
The introduction sets up the debate before it takes a side. It opens on "the age of toxic productivity," grants that planning may pull attention away from the present, and then stakes out a middle position between enjoying the moment and working toward goals. Its last sentence names the two claims the body will defend, purpose and work-life balance, so each body paragraph has a job before it starts.
The evidence comes from three different directions. The first body paragraph pairs Jesus, who "regularly forewarned his disciples of his death," with Musk, whose long-range goals led him to build SpaceX. The second turns to the writer's own schedule. Before learning to make to-do lists, the writer procrastinated, and afterward had "more freedom to invest in my hobbies." The brain paragraph adds a third kind of support, explaining how a plan engages "the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain that controls decision-making and planning." Each paragraph closes by tying its example back to purpose or balance, so the line of reasoning holds across the whole essay.
The sophistication point comes from the counterargument paragraph. The writer lets critics argue that "making plans cannot prepare one for the future" because accidents happen every day, then answers with a practical mechanism. Plans can include "buffer time blocks" for work that unexpected events push aside, so the objection becomes a reason to plan more carefully.
For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.
What Could Be Improved
The brain paragraph explains how planning helps a person "prioritize important tasks first before relaxing," but it stops at productivity. The thesis is about appreciating the present, and the essay never says how finishing tasks sooner turns into enjoying the moment. The science also arrives with no source, so a reader has to take the amygdala claims on faith.
Some of the evidence is shaky. Musk joined Tesla as an early investor after it was founded, and he finished two undergraduate degrees before leaving a Stanford graduate program, so the claim that he passed on "earning a college diploma" does not hold. The Jesus example is also open to dispute, since the Gospels describe healing the sick as a large part of his ministry. Both examples are meant to prove purpose, but a skeptical reader could set them aside on the facts.
Small errors slip in as well. The second body paragraph opens with "plans for the future enables one" where the verb should be plural, and the conclusion has "witht he luckiest people" as a typo.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang argument essay



