4/6 AP English Language Argument Essay: Baca on possessions
This is a real argument essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 4/6 by our AI grader — one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
Prompt 2:
In a 2019 interview, award-winning poet and memoirist Jimmy Santiago Baca asserted: “In America we value possessions. We would much rather talk about a new car than talk about a story that happened between grandfather and me. We’d much rather get on the computer and play video games and enact some cataclysmic¹ epic² than to talk about the epics in our own lives.”
Write an essay that argues your position on the extent to which Baca’s claim about the value of possessions is valid.
The Essay
In American society today, possessions are held to a very high standard to society. New cars, houses, and other exspenive possessions are seen as very valuble and make the owner look much more powerful and succesful. This idea of becoming succefull is now almost entirely based on what possesions they own in their life. American as a country is known for this idea of having the american dream where anyone can become wealthy, and possessions play a huge part in that. Possessions have value in todays society due to the fact that they show ideas of success in one's life, and they make a goal for americans to want better possessions in their life. Although possessions do have value they are not the only thing worth living for, memmories are worth far more than any possesion, but that does not take away the idea that possessions still hold value in society today. The idea of becming succesful in america has been one of the most famous ideas for decades. This idea of the American dream and how one could become rich in the United Sttaes has made the country the way it is. John D Rockefeller was a simple man during the early years of the 20th century. He struck rich and found oil and capitilized on this break through, leading him to become the richest man in america. With this money he bought millions of dollars worth of possessions and showed off his wealth to the country. To america he showed off his sucsess and built upon the idea of the american dream. Through these possesions he was able to also do good in the world, like funding building schools and other neccesities for his community. Rockefeller understood the american dream, but he also understood the common principles that had been laid out for him. His money was used for both good things for the country, and also personal gain. Another major tycoon of that time was Cornelius Vanderbilt. He had made his fourtune from the railroads and spent a lot of his fortune on public education in tennesee. He founded the college Vanderbilt and also had millions of dollars worth of possesions like Rockefeller. While both of these men used their possessions as a sign of success in America, they also gave a lot back to the community. While possessions still inherently hold value, they still are worthless to the idea of giving back and helping others. Those names are still seen on histocial landmarks like Vanderbilt college and rockefeller center in new york. These tycoons of the 20th century showed their possessions showed off their success, but many still decided to give back for that great feeling of being a good person. The idea of the american dream captivates millions to this day and is one of the biggest reasons there has been a rise in millionares over that last 25 years. Many entrepnuears are facicanete dwith the idea of becomeing rich, and one of the biggest benfeits from becoming rich is the possessions you will earn. Americans all would love to become rich and gain more possessions, but do people want to put in the work. Possessions play a huge role in the idea of becoming rich and they drag millions of americans into this get money life where nothing is ever good enough. A cycle where one can always make more money is the reason why work culutre is becming more and more toxic every year. Scams, ai generated vides, and drop shiping are all new ways people are using to try and become rich. While the determination to become rich is not a bad idea, it can ruin a peron's life if the only care is about money or possessions. On instagram and tik tok many users now post videos about how they got rich. They used ai clips and started selling cheap products from china for higher prices. These videos which are clealry targeted for kids and teenagers lead many to buy the course that the video uploader is selling, or waste money buying things that will never sell. This new age of wanting to become rich is much different than before and the common principles of life are going out the window. This is all done through social media and the idea of being able to afford nice possessions if you do this guide that the blogger is telling you to do. So while possessions still hold immense value in society today, they are still worthless comapred to memmories one can make with their family instaed of trying to cheat their way to becoming a millionare. The idea of possessions holding value will never go away in american society. People will always want more than they have, and will want to achieve this american dream of becming rich and powerful. The goal that possessions make for americans, as well as the fact they show signs of success, all prove that possesions hold value in Ameircan society. The american dream is good thing for american society, only if the ealry principles are still followed. Whether it is the old tycoons of the 20th centrry like vanderbilt or rockefller, or these new bloggers, america must know that while possessions do hold value they are not the only thing that is worth value. A hug from a loved one or a memmory with a grandparent is worth far more than a car, a house, or any other possession will ever be.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Evidence & Commentary (3/4)
Sophistication (0/1)
Why This Essay Scored Well
The opening paragraph takes a qualified position on Baca's claim. The writer grants that possessions "show ideas of success in one's life" and "make a goal for americans," then limits the claim with "memmories are worth far more than any possesion." Two reasons plus a limit give the essay a clear line of reasoning to follow.
The body paragraphs bring in evidence from two eras. The second paragraph uses the tycoons of an earlier century, saying Rockefeller "showed off his wealth to the country" and pointing to landmarks that still carry the names, "Vanderbilt college and rockefeller center in new york." The third paragraph moves to the present with get-rich videos on social media and describes how they work, since the posters "used ai clips and started selling cheap products from china for higher prices." Pairing an old version of the American dream with a new one is a good structural choice, because it suggests the link between possessions and success has lasted for more than a century.
The writer also keeps the memories-versus-possessions contrast alive at the ends of paragraphs. The third paragraph closes by calling possessions "still worthless comapred to memmories one can make with their family," and the conclusion ends on a concrete image, "A hug from a loved one or a memmory with a grandparent." That repeated contrast is the essay's most consistent thread, and it keeps the response tied to Baca's own comparison of a new car with a story about a grandfather.
For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.
What Could Be Improved
Commentary is where the essay lost a point. The tycoon paragraph says what Rockefeller and Vanderbilt owned, then turns to their charity, and the sentence "While possessions still inherently hold value, they still are worthless to the idea of giving back and helping others" pulls against the claim the paragraph set out to prove. The influencer paragraph drifts the same way into toxic work culture and scams. Each paragraph needed a closing sentence explaining how its example shows Americans valuing possessions.
Some history details are also off. Rockefeller's oil fortune was built in the 1870s and 1880s, decades before "the early years of the 20th century," and he made it refining and selling oil. Rockefeller Center was built by his son. Vanderbilt's gift that founded the university was about $1 million, a small share of his fortune. The opposing view, that possessions are a fair measure of a life, gets a single clause and is never answered, which kept the essay from the sophistication point.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang argument essay



