FRQuick

5/6 AP English Language Argument Essay: Perfection

This is a real argument essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 5/6 by our AI grader — one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.

The Prompt

Many people spend long hours trying to achieve perfection in their personal or professional lives.  Similarly, people often demand perfection from others, creating expectations that may be challenging to live up to.  In contrast, some people think perfection is not attainable or desirable.

Write an essay that argues your position on the value of striving for perfection.

In your response you should do the following:

  • Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position.
  • Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning.
  • Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
  • Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.

The Essay

Throughout human history, perfection has been intertwined as a societal expectation and is the ultimate desire for most individuals. But if true perfection is deemed impossible to achieve, why does our species strive so hard to achieve it? This is because striving for perfection is more than not making mistakes, it's the value of the skills, maturity and personal growth derived from chasing the unattainable. First, striving for perfection allows for personal growth and maturity. This is prevalant in the show Re;Zero, a story of 17 year old Natsuki Subaru who was teleported to a unknown dangerous world. In this world he gains the abillity to go back to checkpoints in the past everytime he dies. Throughout this story, Subaru has to constantly protect his friends, loved ones, and own well-being from the various evils of this world. But everytime he tries to fix something, more wrongs appear. This leads him to make complex decisions throughout the series to decide who and what he has to save, and the worth of his own life. At the beginning of the series Subaru was an egosistical selfish shut-in. But as he strives for a perfect present, correcting every mistake that he believes he has made previously, he realizes how to be an altruistic, selfless hero who is mature enough to make complex decisions impacting the future. Though he cannot change the present into his perfect reality, the value gained from striving for this perfection is apparent throughout the end of this story and specifically characterized by the mental, and physical fortitude in his actions. Secondly, the renowned basketball player Kobe Bryant embodies the value of skills and personal growth from chasing perfection. This is shown by Kobe arriving at the gym earlier than any of his teamates, with the goal of perfecting his basketball shooting every single day. This punctuallity allowed him to not only get better at physical basketball skills, but allow him to grow his determination, perserverance, and mentality. Backing this, the more days Kobe chased perfection, the better it showed in his basketball games. Eventually, because of his determination, he reached the highest award in a basketball season: Most Valuable Player. When asked what his advice was for the future generation, he claims the mamba mentality (an individuals grit and desire for perfection) is what drives them to be the best they can be. As humans, we constantly strive for this concept of perfection, that we cannot fully comphrehend. But no matter how far we close we get or how far away perfection is, the determination to chase perfection manifests itself in the value gained mentally, physically, and emotionally.

Score Breakdown

Thesis (1/1)

Evidence & Commentary (4/4)

Sophistication (0/1)

Why This Essay Scored Well

The thesis answers the essay's opening question with a position someone could argue against. The writer claims that striving for perfection "is more than not making mistakes, it's the value of the skills, maturity and personal growth derived from chasing the unattainable." That move puts the value in the effort, so the essay never has to prove that perfection is reachable. Each body paragraph then opens on one part of that claim, starting with "First, striving for perfection allows for personal growth and maturity," which keeps the line of reasoning easy to follow.

The anime paragraph does the most careful work. The writer explains the show's premise in two sentences, then describes Subaru at the start as an "egosistical selfish shut-in" and at the end as "an altruistic, selfless hero." That before and after gives the growth claim something concrete to point to. The paragraph's last sentence also admits the limit of the example, "Though he cannot change the present into his perfect reality," and still draws the claim from it. The admission fits the thesis exactly, since the essay argues that the chase matters even when perfection stays out of reach.

The Kobe Bryant paragraph applies the same pattern to a real athlete. The writer names a specific habit, arriving at the gym early "with the goal of perfecting his basketball shooting every single day," and says it built his "determination, perserverance, and mentality" along with his shot. The MVP award gives the habit a result, and the mamba mentality line lets Bryant's own advice close the paragraph. With one fictional example and one real one, the essay shows its pattern holding in two very different places.

For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.

What Could Be Improved

The Kobe paragraph asserts its key link. "Backing this, the more days Kobe chased perfection, the better it showed in his basketball games" tells the reader the practice paid off without showing how. A specific season, game or skill would turn that sentence into evidence.

The essay also never takes on the opposing view, which is why it missed the sophistication point. The opening question, "But if true perfection is deemed impossible to achieve, why does our species strive so hard to achieve it?" raises the objection and moves on. A short section giving that view its best case (chasing perfection can burn people out or leave them never satisfied) and then answering it would add the complexity the argument lacks. The conclusion is a natural place for it, since "As humans, we constantly strive for this concept of perfection, that we cannot fully comphrehend" mostly restates the thesis. Spelling slips such as "prevalant," "abillity" and "punctuallity" don't cost points here, but they are worth a proofread.

Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.

Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang argument essay

Related Essays