FRQuick

6/6 AP English Language Rhetorical Analysis Essay: Thatcher

This is a real rhetorical analysis essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 6/6 by FRQuick's free AI AP Lang essay grader. It is one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.

The Prompt

On June 11, 2004, Margaret Thatcher, the former prime minister of Great Britain, delivered the following eulogy to the American people in honor of former United States president Ronald Reagan, with whom she had worked closely. Read the eulogy carefully. Then, in a well-developed essay, analyze the rhetorical strategies that Thatcher uses to convey her message.

The Passage

We have lost a great president, a great American, and a great man, and I have lost a dear friend. In his lifetime, Ronald Reagan was such a cheerful and invigorating presence that it was easy to forget what daunting historic tasks he set himself. He sought to mend America’s wounded spirit, to restore the strength of the free world, and to free the slaves of communism. These were causes hard to accomplish and heavy with risk, yet they were pursued with almost a lightness of spirit, for Ronald Reagan also embodied another great cause, what Arnold Bennett once called "the great cause of cheering us all up". His policies had a freshness and optimism that won converts from every class and every nation, and ultimately, from the very heart of the "evil empire." Yet his humour often had a purpose beyond humour. In the terrible hours after the attempt on his life, his easy jokes gave reassurance to an anxious world. They were evidence that in the aftermath of terror and in the midst of hysteria one great heart at least remained sane and jocular. They were truly grace under pressure. And perhaps they signified grace of a deeper kind. Ronnie himself certainly believed that he had been given back his life for a purpose. As he told a priest after his recovery, "Whatever time I’ve got left now belongs to the big fella upstairs." And surely, it is hard to deny that Ronald Reagan’s life was providential when we look at what he achieved in the eight years that followed. Others prophesied the decline of the West. He inspired America and its allies with renewed faith in their mission of freedom. Others saw only limits to growth. He transformed a stagnant economy into an engine of opportunity. Others hoped, at best, for an uneasy cohabitation with the Soviet Union. He won the Cold War, not only without firing a shot, but also by inviting enemies out of their fortress and turning them into friends. I cannot imagine how any diplomat or any dramatist could improve on his words to Mikhail Gorbachev at the Geneva summit. "Let me tell you why it is we distrust you." Those words are candid and tough, and they cannot have been easy to hear. But they are also a clear invitation to a new beginning and a new relationship that would be rooted in trust. We live today in the world that Ronald Reagan began to reshape with those words. It is a very different world, with different challenges and new dangers. All in all, however, it is one of greater freedom and prosperity, one more hopeful than the world he inherited on becoming president. As Prime Minister, I worked closely with Ronald Reagan for eight of the most important years of all our lives. We talked regularly, both before and after his presidency, and I’ve had time and cause to reflect on what made him a great president. Ronald Reagan knew his own mind. He had firm principles and, I believe, right ones. He expounded them clearly. He acted upon them decisively. When the world threw problems at the White House, he was not baffled or disorientated or overwhelmed. He knew almost instinctively what to do. When his aides were preparing option papers for his decision, they were able to cut out entire rafts of proposals that they knew the old man would never wear. When his allies came under Soviet or domestic pressure, they could look confidently to Washington for firm leadership, and when his enemies tested American resolve, they soon discovered that his resolve was firm and unyielding. Yet his ideas, so clear, were never simplistic. He saw the many sides of truth. Yes, he warned that the Soviet Union had an insatiable drive for military power and territorial expansion, but he also sensed that it was being eaten away by systemic failures impossible to reform. Yes, he did not shrink from denouncing Moscow’s evil empire, but he realized that a man of good will might nonetheless emerge from within its dark corridors. So the president resisted Soviet expansion and pressed down on Soviet weakness at every point until the day came when communism began to collapse beneath the combined weight of those pressures and its own failures. And when a man of good will did emerge from the ruins, President Reagan stepped forward to shake his hand and to offer sincere cooperation. Nothing was more typical of Ronald Reagan than that large-hearted magnanimity, and nothing was more American. Therein lies perhaps the final explanation of his achievements. Ronald Reagan carried the American people with him in his great endeavours because there was perfect sympathy between them. He and they loved America and what it stands for: freedom and opportunity for ordinary people.

The Essay

In her eulogy, Margaret Thatcher portrays Ronald Reagan as this great, humorous, and principled President, who undertook many heavy tasks, but ultimately did it out of love for his country; she wants her audience not only to see him that way, but to know why. However, instead of simply listing the historic achievements he made, she uses personal memories to establish credibility, showing a deep, intimate relationship between them. She shows that his humour served a greater purpose than humour; in contrast, she also recalls how he was also at the same time firm and unyielding, though always open for cooperation. With these seemingly polar opposite ways she portrays him, she combines them to show her audience why he was a great president. In doing so, her audience is likely to view him the way she did. From the first sentence, we observe the change in the personal preposition from “We have lost a great president” to “I have lost a dear friend.” It makes clear that Margaret Thatcher knew Ronald Reagan personally, establishing her credibility to talk about him and to influence how the audience might view him. The words “dear friend” reveal a close relationship—they weren’t simply allies or political partners; they were deep friends. The purpose is to evoke emotion in the audience who may sympathize with her. “Ronald Reagan was such a cheerful and invigorating presence…” and “Yet his humour often had a purpose beyond humour.” She names a key personality trait—his humor was not simply his character; it was the very defining factor that made him such a great, composed president. As she concedes, his presidency was not all easy, but his humor served a greater purpose than jokes—it was assurance. In addition, “They were truly grace under pressure.” His humour shows something deeper: it was grace for those around him. This complicates how the audience is to view him, because the humour was not simply a witty joke or a lighthearted personality. He also showed people close to him—like Margaret Thatcher—the sense of purpose he had in accomplishing these things, and, therefore, to trust him. His humour revealed much about his character. This explains why he seemed so composed in times of distress and she does not simply state: “He was a confident guy.” Secondly, we also see the coexistence of his lightheartedness and his determination in the things he accomplished as she says, “I cannot imagine how any diplomat or any dramatist could improve on his words to Mikhail Gorbachev at the Geneva summit, ‘Let me tell you why it is we distrust you.’ Those words are candid and tough, and they cannot have been easy to hear.” “Let me tell you why it is we distrust you.” This phrase has some force and a serious tone, showing the audience that, though he may have been funny, he was also straight and plain. Therein lies the complex dynamic of one being funny and being straight, to the point, and decisive. She shows her audience that he did not compromise on his values and principles—especially trust. Those characteristics, though seemingly contradictory, were exactly what drove him to do all that he did. “Ronald Reagan knew his own mind. He had firm principles and, I believe, right ones. He expounded them clearly. He acted upon them decisively. When the world threw problems at the White House, he was not baffled or disorientated or overwhelmed.” His humour brought calm and clarity under pressure as she says, “he was not baffled or disorientated or overwhelmed.” His firmness drove his decisions as evident in, “He had firm principles…He acted upon them decisively.” The audience now can see him as not simply a nice guy. They can see him as someone who used his humour to be a confident presence in the midst of the chaos of the Cold War and, at the same time, someone who was uncompromising in his value for trust, firmness, and unyieldingness, as evident in “When his allies came under Soviet or domestic pressure, they could look confidently to Washington for firm leadership, and when his enemies tested the American resolve, they soon discovered that his resolve was firm and unyielding.” These seemingly contradictory traits coexisted to establish confidence and to pursue what was right for the American resolve, explaining exactly why he was the effective president the world knew. In conclusion, Margaret Thatcher accomplishes her purpose of showing her audience that Ronald Reagan was a great president, principled man, and a dear friend. She first establishes her credibility by showing her intimate relationship with him, allowing her audience to become receptive to how she viewed him. She combines his humour and unyielding compromise to explain the purpose with which he did things and the reason for his success—always for the American people.

Score Breakdown

Thesis (1/1)

Evidence & Commentary (4/4)

Sophistication (1/1)

Why This Essay Scored Well

The thesis gives the essay a clear problem to solve. The writer reads Thatcher's portrait of Reagan as two "seemingly polar opposite" traits, humor and firmness, and argues that she "combines them to show her audience why he was a great president." Every body paragraph returns to one side of that pair or the place where the two meet.

The first body paragraph starts with the eulogy's opening line. The writer notices the shift from "We have lost a great president" to "I have lost a dear friend" and explains its effect. The friendship gives Thatcher standing to describe Reagan's character, and "The purpose is to evoke emotion in the audience who may sympathize with her." The same paragraph then reads the passage about the assassination attempt closely. Thatcher admits that Reagan's humor might look light, and the writer argues that it worked as reassurance, so "the humour was not simply a witty joke or a lighthearted personality."

The sophistication point works differently from the other rows, because it rests on one sustained idea, the tension between humor and firmness. In the second body paragraph the writer sets the Geneva summit line beside the earlier humor and names "the complex dynamic of one being funny and being straight, to the point, and decisive." The third body paragraph carries that idea into Thatcher's lines about allies and enemies testing American resolve and closes with "These seemingly contradictory traits coexisted to establish confidence." Holding two traits that seem to pull apart, and showing Thatcher using both to persuade, is the essay's most complex move.

For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.

What Could Be Improved

Some paragraphs lean on long quotations with little commentary between them. The second body paragraph ends on five full sentences from the eulogy, from "Ronald Reagan knew his own mind" to "overwhelmed," with nothing after them. The third paragraph then quotes "he was not baffled or disorientated or overwhelmed" as proof of Reagan's humor, but that line comes from Thatcher's praise of his decisiveness, and the essay never shows how the two connect.

The essay also skips the eulogy's most visible structure. The three short paragraphs that open with "Others" and answer with "He" set Reagan against everyone who expected decline, and that contrast fits the essay's argument about his firmness. A few word choices need fixing as well. The opening shift from "We" to "I" is a change in pronoun, which the essay calls a "personal preposition," and the conclusion's "unyielding compromise" says the opposite of what the writer means.

Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.

Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang rhetorical analysis essay

Related Essays