3/6 AP English Language Rhetorical Analysis Essay: Swift
This is a real rhetorical analysis essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 3/6 by FRQuick's free AI AP Lang essay grader. It is one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
On May 18, 2022, singer and songwriter Taylor Swift delivered a commencement address to the graduating class of New York University at Yankee Stadium in New York City. Swift, who began her music career as a teenager. In the following excerpt, she reflects on her experiences and offers advice to graduates preparing to enter a new stage of their lives. Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Swift makes to convey her message in the excerpt about pursuing personal goals.
The Passage
The Essay
In Taylor Swift's commencement address to New York University graduates on May 18th, 2022, she reflects on her past experiences and offers advice to the graduates. Taylor Swift is concerned about effortlessness and being unbothered. Taylor Swift's message is that people go on in life and have changes, but cringe always exists, so they should learn to embrace it. However, she faces the challenge of the graduates living in this age where being nonchalant, effortless, and unbothered have been perceived as cool and being cringe and trying to achieve personal goals is seen as uncool. To address this problem in her speech, she makes the choices to include a personal story and to include a list about different writing styles and genres. With this, she hopes to make the graduates embrace the cringe in their lives and believe that trying and pursuing personal goals is not a negative thing. In the beginning of the excerpt, Taylor Swift uses a personal story of herself to contradict what the audience believes about being cringe and contrast that with all the positive things that happened during that time. She describes herself dressing up as a "1950s housewife", but she also says that she had a lot of fun. Taylor Swift mentioning that she dressed up as a housewife goes against the graduates’ view of her. However, she contrasts that with the fun she had. This then connects back to her purpose, because she wants the graduates to believe that being cringe is not a bad thing and that they should embrace it. If the students embrace the cringe and actually pursue their personal goals, Taylor Swift has achieved her purpose. Her choice initially makes the graduates think warily of her as it goes against their beliefs of being cringe, but as she describes all the fun she had while being cringe, it makes the cringe appear like a positive thing. Towards the end of the excerpt, Taylor Swift lists several situations and then contrasts that with the writing styles used during those situations to show that everyone changes over time. She mentions, "Instagram stories,” "senior thesis,” "email to your boss,” and "your best friend from home.” All these different situations will require different writing styles, some may be serious and some may be informal. Basically, Taylor Swift is comparing the list to people's lives, saying that as people go through life and encounter different experiences, they will change themselves. The graduates, as college students, have already experienced many of these different situations, so this list becomes very relatable and easy to understand for them. This also connects back to the previous point about being cringe because as time goes on, certain things are seen as more or less cringe, but that should be completely unregarded and graduates should still pursue their personal goals. This choice makes the audience feel that as time goes on, there will be so many new experiences which may be cringe, but pursuing their goals should not be cringe.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Evidence & Commentary (2/4)
Sophistication (0/1)
What This Essay Gets Right
The thesis names two choices, a personal story and a list of writing situations, and ties them to Swift's purpose. She hopes, the writer says, "to make the graduates embrace the cringe in their lives and believe that trying and pursuing personal goals is not a negative thing." The introduction also identifies the obstacle she faces, a generation that treats being "nonchalant, effortless, and unbothered" as cool.
The evidence is well chosen. The first body paragraph uses Swift's "1950s housewife" phase, and the second quotes the list of writing situations, from "Instagram stories" and "senior thesis" to "email to your boss." The second paragraph also brings the audience into the analysis, noting that the graduates, "as college students, have already experienced many of these different situations."
What Went Wrong (And How to Avoid It)
The essay earns 2 of 4 in Evidence and Commentary because its commentary names effects without explaining them. The first body paragraph says the housewife story "makes the cringe appear like a positive thing" but never points to the words that change the graduates' reaction, such as Swift's follow-up "I was having fun." The second paragraph calls the list "very relatable and easy to understand," which describes the audience's response without showing why recognizing their own writing habits would make them accept her point about change.
The two body paragraphs also sit side by side. The sentence meant to link them, "This also connects back to the previous point about being cringe," announces a connection that the paragraph never develops, so the essay reads as two separate devices.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang rhetorical analysis essay



