FRQuick

6/6 AP English Language Rhetorical Analysis Essay: Gates

This is a real rhetorical analysis essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 6/6 by FRQuick's free AI AP Lang essay grader. It is one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.

The Prompt

In June 2024, philanthropist Melinda French Gates delivered the commencement address at Stanford University. In the following excerpt, Gates reflects on personal and professional transitions as she addresses graduates preparing to begin a new stage of their lives. Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Gates makes to convey her message about identity during times of change.

The Passage

Section 1 The spiritual leader Ram Dass had a wonderful teaching about two waves traveling through the ocean, one big and one small. And as the waves get closer to the land, the big wave sees what’s about to happen. They see all the waves ahead of them are just crashing onto the shore. And devastated, the big wave says to the small wave—he warns them the end is near. And the small wave just smiles and says, “Don’t worry, we’ll be fine.” “You don’t understand,” the big wave insists. “We’re done for.” And the smaller wave is just totally calm and says, “No, we’re not. And I can explain why in just six words: You’re not a wave. You’re water.” I love that story. It captures what it’s like to experience an enormous transition without losing the core of who you are. I turned 60 this year, and you don’t get to be my age without navigating all kinds of transitions: some you embraced and some you never expected, some you hoped for and some you fought as hard as you could. For me, those included starting my career at Microsoft, losing one of my very best friends to cancer, falling in love, having children, starting my work on behalf of women and girls, and ending a marriage and partnership of almost 30 years, and very recently making a major career shift. In each case, there was a moment that I felt like that big wave, terrified that life as I knew it was about to be over. But I always made it to the next day, and so will you. And I’ve learned that the next day is when the real work begins, because what we do the next day is what makes us who we are. So in addition to honoring all of your accomplishments today, I also want to offer you something to think about when you wake up tomorrow: three lessons I’ve learned from my own experience with transitions. SECTION 2 The first piece of advice is to enter these moments with radical open-heartedness. Most of the time, we walk around through life in the thicket of our everyday routine. But during a transition, we step out of our familiar surroundings into a big, wide-open space where everything is new. And there are two ways to encounter these spaces. You can keep your head down and focus on finding the shortest distance possible from one familiar thing to the next. Or you can find the courage to linger in that liminal space and see what it has to tell you. That, to me, is practicing open-heartedness. I have to admit, as a young person, I managed transitions in the first way. I had a list of goals I wanted to accomplish, and as soon as I checked one off the list, I raced across the clearing to the next one, ’cause frankly it was a lot less scary that way. But as I’ve gotten older, I’ve learned the value of embracing uncertainty. I’ll give you one example of what this has looked like in my life. When I entered philanthropy more than 25 years ago, it was completely unfamiliar terrain. I didn’t have any experience in global health or development yet, so I had a lot to learn, and I knew I’d need to pay attention. Now initially, we thought the foundation’s work was going to focus on vaccine access. But when I started traveling around the world to see the work in action, the women I met kept changing the subject. They’d say, “What about the shots I used to get?” they’d ask me, and they were talking about contraceptives. So I stopped, and I listened to what they had to say. And soon I was talking about contraceptives on almost all my trips and continuing those conversations back home with my team. And those conversations led to others. I learned how much society benefits when women are able to make their own decisions, control their own resources, and direct their own futures. And I began to focus my efforts there instead. I think back now to those early trips with such gratitude because the women I met took me in a new direction, and they led me to my life’s work. SECTION 3 Now you are Stanford students, so I imagine most of you are graduating today with big plans for yourselves: higher degrees to earn, causes to advance, companies to start, industries to disrupt. Those big, bold plans are wonderful, and the world needs you. But my advice is to leave some room for those plans to change. Resist the idea that anything you’ve done here at Stanford has already locked you into one path or any one kind of career. Be excited about the fact that you will encounter possibilities you haven’t even imagined, and be willing to let what you learn shift your thinking about what you’re here on this Earth to do. Remember that once the wave learns to call itself by a different name, once it realizes it’s not just a wave but it is water, it becomes free to take on new forms. And the same is true for you.

The Essay

In her 2024 commencement address at Stanford University, Melinda French Gates encourages graduates to remain open to change without feeling that they are losing who they are. This may challenge students whose goals and careful planning have helped them succeed. Through the story of two waves, her personal experience, and direct advice, Gates shows that changing direction can help graduates discover their purpose rather than abandon it. Gates first uses the story of two waves to challenge the idea that a major change means losing one’s identity. The big wave fears that reaching the shore means destruction, but the smaller wave explains, “You’re not a wave. You’re water.” A wave has a temporary shape, while water remains even when that shape changes. Because reaching Stanford and graduating likely required years of working toward specific goals, these students may see a clear path as proof that they know who they are. Changing that path could therefore feel like losing the identity they worked to build. The water metaphor reassures them that leaving a familiar role does not erase the qualities they bring to it. Gates then admits that she has felt “terrified” during her own transitions. By acknowledging fear despite her accomplishments, she shows graduates that uncertainty does not mean they are unprepared or unsuccessful. Her reassurance that she reached “the next day, and so will you” makes change seem manageable. However, calling that next day the beginning of “the real work” also challenges them to see their identity as something shaped by how they respond to change, rather than something permanently defined by their current plans. After reassuring graduates that change does not erase their identities, Gates uses her experience in philanthropy to show why allowing plans to change can be valuable. She admits that, when younger, she hurried from one goal to another because it was “a lot less scary.” This confession recognizes the comfort that clear plans may offer ambitious graduates and helps her appear humble through her vulnerability instead of judgemental. Her later experience provides another approach: although the foundation initially focused on vaccines, women’s questions about contraceptives made her stop and listen. Their concerns eventually led her to her “life’s work.” The example shows that changing direction did not leave her without purpose; listening helped her find it. To graduates who are seeking security through focusing on singular goals, this gives them a reason to remain open. They may find more meaningful work through remaining open. Gates then lists the graduates’ ambitions, including companies to start and causes to advance, and calls those plans “wonderful.” By respecting their goals for ocntreibutionbefore asking them to “leave some room” for change, she avoids suggesting that their hard work or ambition is misguided. Returning to the water story, she explains that they are free to “take on new forms” during periods of transition. It allows the graduates who feel that the pull to meet goals not to feel that they have failed if they change paths, but rather that Their plans can change while their ability to contribute remains. Gates encourages graduates to carry their ambition forward without treating their current goals as permanent definitions of themselves. Remaining open to uncertainty allows them to discover possibilities that careful planning alone cannot reveal.

Score Breakdown

Thesis (1/1)

Evidence & Commentary (4/4)

Sophistication (1/1)

Why This Essay Scored Well

The thesis names three choices, the wave story, Gates's personal experience, and her direct advice, and claims they show "that changing direction can help graduates discover their purpose." Each body paragraph advances that claim, the first through the water metaphor and the second through her philanthropy.

The first body paragraph explains why the water metaphor matters to this audience in particular. The writer reasons that "these students may see a clear path as proof that they know who they are," so changing course could feel like losing an identity they worked to build. The line "You're not a wave. You're water" answers that fear. The paragraph follows it with Gates's admission that she felt "terrified," which the writer reads as evidence that uncertainty does not mean failure.

The sophistication point comes from one move in the second body paragraph, where the writer tracks the order of Gates's appeals. She calls the graduates' plans "wonderful" before asking them to "leave some room" for change, and the writer argues that this sequence lets her challenge their ambition without suggesting their hard work was misguided. Earlier in that paragraph, the essay reads her confession that she rushed between goals because it was "a lot less scary" as a way to seem humble to ambitious listeners.

For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.

What Could Be Improved

The weakest sentence follows the contraceptive example. The essay says "this gives them a reason to remain open" and then repeats the idea in the next sentence without explaining what about the example would persuade a graduate who wants security. Linking the example back to Gates's admission that the fast path felt "a lot less scary" would show the mechanism.

Proofreading would also help. The second body paragraph runs "ocntreibution" into the next word and capitalizes "Their" mid-sentence. The two-sentence conclusion restates the thesis and adds little.

Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.

Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang rhetorical analysis essay

Related Essays