5/6 AP English Language Rhetorical Analysis Essay: Gates
This is a real rhetorical analysis essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 5/6 by FRQuick's free AI AP Lang essay grader. It is one of many AP English Language essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Gates makes to convey her message about identity during times of change.
The Passage
The Essay
Melinda French Gates delivered a commencement address at Stanford University to graduates, staff, and families in June 2024. She was called upon to address graduates as they move on with their lives, and offer insight to everyone there. As a philanthropist, her job is to make an effort to improve people’s quality of life, which impacts the graduates as they know to treat her words seriously. Gates wanted the graduates to understand that people can adapt to enormous transitions in life, and navigate change if they are open minded as it will bring exciting possibilities. However, the graduates could feel as if they must stick to one goal and remain consistent, and fear what will happen next in their lives, which could blind them to Gates' message of her commencement address. To combat this, Gates purposefully shares an anecdote about a big wave's fear and a small wave navigating change with crashing into a shore, listing examples of changes that can happen in life, and contrasts and compares what they think they know against what they don’t and what's to come. So, as graduates listen to the commencement address, she wants them to be open-minded and through that navigate change. Gates begins by presenting an anecdote regarding a big wave and a small wave, and how they embrace change as they crash into shore. First, she depicts their dialogue and as the big waves fear is shown, the small wave comforts them stating, “You’re not a wave. You’re water.” Identifying the big waves ear being crashing into the shore, and being calmed down is essential as the big wave realizes that it’s water, meaning it wouldn’t change or disappear after confronting change. By revealing the big waves and the small waves conversation, she highlights that people can adapt and take different forms, and that after an enormous transition, people don’t change their identity. It makes things like an extreme career shift feel less like ending as it offers a metaphor that your career doesn’t change but takes a different form .She uses this anecdote as a way to reflect the current state of the graduates, as they are about to experience a big transition into life. Gates anticipates that the graduates are afraid, and nervous about what will happen to them after Stanford. “You’re not a wave. You’re water,” also offers the graduates to develop a new way of thinking of the story differently. The metaphor loosens their fear of crashing into the shore, or in the graduates case not doing good within the next chapter of their life. However, calling them water is like saying being fluid with the next chapter of their lives, which means acclimating or adjusting with confronting change. That encourages the graduates, and even the families to think of how they could combat enormous changes in their lives. Thus, Gates’s concept of taking a new form and retaining your identity after change reframes from not retaining their identities after big changes for the graduates as they begin to embrace a new chapter of their lives. Within the next words of her speech, she lists changes of what can happen in life, and specifically what has occurred in her life, which reveals to the graduates that changes occur in life, strong or weak, good or bad. So, she lists the transitions that she has navigated including, “losing one of her very best friends to cancer, falling in love, and starting her career at Microsoft,”. By highlighting the transitions that she has gone through, she applies her teachings to her own experiences, and offers a sense of comfortability and relatability. She even goes as far as saying, “[Each] moment I felt like that big wave,” but stated, “I always made it to the next day.” That big wave represents being fearful and anxious of embracing change, and within her next sentence, she states that she ended up overcoming those fears. By highlighting this comparison of life to the story, she gives the graduates a newer look of their situation because of the lesson of the story, which is that a person doesn’t always change after a transition, they take a different form of themselves. Hearing Gates' own losses makes the graduate trust her advice, as hearing the extremity of hers, and the bittersweet changes in her life allows them to relate to her, and realize she has gone through many things and still made it through. It is more than likely that the graduates are still fearful of moving on to the next chapter, so she purposefully uses her words to instill confidence in them that they will push through the change. Gates then uses an anecdote of the waves to reveal that people can adapt to change, and retain different forms. This builds on that by bringing it to life and giving a newer perspective by comparing the story to changes in life; it makes the graduates be able to instill in their hands the idea that within their lives change occurs. Thus, Gates created this idea of pushing forward after change which could have potentially reframed the thinking that it’s impossible to embrace change for the graduates as they realize that it is possible to navigate and embrace change, especially with that amount of changes that occur in life.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Evidence & Commentary (4/4)
Sophistication (0/1)
Why This Essay Scored Well
The introduction sets up the rhetorical situation before it names any device. It describes Gates as a philanthropist addressing graduates who "could feel as if they must stick to one goal and remain consistent," and then presents her choices as answers to that fear. The thesis ties the wave anecdote and the list of life changes to her purpose, that graduates can "navigate change if they are open minded," and each body paragraph takes up one of those choices in order.
The wave paragraph explains how the metaphor works on this audience. The writer reads "You're not a wave. You're water" as a reframing, saying it "makes things like an extreme career shift feel less like ending." The paragraph then ties the image to the graduates' own worry about "not doing good within the next chapter of their life," so the metaphor is read through the people hearing it.
The second body paragraph connects Gates's list of transitions to her line "I always made it to the next day." The writer reads the big wave as Gates's own fear and the following sentence as proof that she survived it, which gives the graduates a model to follow. That attention to how her personal history works on the audience carries the commentary to the top score.
For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.
What Could Be Improved
Sophistication is the missing point. The two body paragraphs each cover one choice and stop, so the essay reads as two parallel observations. A connection between them, such as how the wave story prepares graduates for Gates's later advice to "leave some room for those plans to change," would show the choices building one argument.
The commentary also repeats itself. The second body paragraph restates the wave metaphor with "This builds on that by bringing it to life and giving a newer perspective by comparing the story to changes in life," which adds no new claim. The sentence "Hearing Gates' own losses makes the graduate trust her advice" names the result without the cause. The space spent on restatement could have gone to what one specific loss, such as the friend Gates lost to cancer, does to listeners who fear their own next step.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Language essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lang rhetorical analysis essay



