5/6 AP English Literature Literary Argument Essay Example #10
This is a real literary argument essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 5/6 by our AI grader — one of many AP English Literature essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
Many works of literature feature a character who holds a secret that can have broader implications for that character or other characters. For example, such secrets may create conflict, provide a source of consolation, protect characters from reality, or allow one character to manipulate other characters. Either from your own reading or from the list below, choose a work of fiction in which an important character holds a secret that affects that character’s relationship with one or more other characters. Then, in a well-written essay, analyze how the effect of the character’s secret contributes to an interpretation of the work as a whole. Do not merely summarize the plot.
The Essay
In the Gothic Novel Frankenstein Mary Shelly follows Victor Frankenstein and his path towards a creation of a higher being the Frankenstein monster. In the story the main character Victor Frankenstein is highly educated, with a sophisticated background and highly ambitious. Due to his ambitious behavier we see a lot of his self destructive tendency illustrating the harm that unchecked ambition may lead to. In Frankenstein the main character Victor Frankenstein due to many secrets which he misattributes leads to the devastating death of many significant characters such as Justine and Elizabeth. Ultimately illustrating the failure to understand one self and the indirect destructive power that secrets may hold even when we believe it's better for one another or society. One key instance when Victor Frankenstein withholds information is during Justines trial, due to him withholding the secret about the Frankenstein monster he leads her to be falsely executed. Victor falsely convinces himself that people may not believe him, that the information will only lead to mass hysteria and no good can come from it. Although this may be true, a lot of his inner reasoning is due to self preservation although he may have some good intentions he is truly worried about his self perception, what people may think of him and whether people may think he's a madman. Due to this protective tendency of himself he leads to the death of a deeply beloved family member. Furthermore after the death he further grieves and curses the monster without acknowledging that he played a big part in her death, that his secrecy borned her death and he had the control to let her live. Not only does he withhold secrets about people that may have saved their lives, he withholds the secret about the creature. Victor withholds the secret about his creation due to his perception that he has created this abhorrent creature and what people may think about him and his reputation. Although he believes he is shielding society from this monster, his secret holding and lack of accountability to care for the creature leads to deep grief for the monster himself. The monsters lack of nurture due to Victor secrecy leads the monster to go down a dark path of destruction, he develops self destructive tendency and deep rage. He questions why he has been abandoned kept secret away this deep strife that occurs that Victor does not acknowledge show his actions, failing to acknowledge that he directly impacted him, he only calls him abhorred, disgusting vowing vengeance towards him when in reality all this strife is due to his secrecy. At the end of the story after all the events have occurred and Victor is on his deathbed Victor warns Walton not only about the creature but the pursuit of ambition. This pivotal scene shows a contrast from Victor at the beginning being his hubris self believing that situations need to be dealt with by him, the narrative must be controlled by him to the end, which he finally somewhat recognizes his mistakes. This demonstrates the chronology of his secret holding. He no longer fears ridicule and is truly interested in helping the future generation, he tells Walton about not only the monster begging him to end him but stopping his pursuit that this behavior is self destructive. This is highly ironic as when Victor finally reveals his secret his words become of use and benefit others. Although this is a path in the right direction Victor plead for Walton to continue chasing the monster highlights how even after all the events his yearn for vengeance is still incomplete. Victor only learns when he has lost everything that his own implications have harm and through his last dying moment we see the power that secrets hold within oneself.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Evidence & Commentary (4/4)
Sophistication (0/1)
Why This Essay Scored Well
The essay ties the prompt's secret to a specific cost. The introduction says Victor's secrets lead "to the devastating death of many significant characters such as Justine and Elizabeth," and its last sentence widens the claim to "the indirect destructive power that secrets may hold even when we believe it's better for one another or society." That final phrase sets up the essay's main interest, the gap between the reasons Victor gives for his silence and the reasons underneath.
The Justine paragraph is where that interest pays off. The writer lists the reasons Victor gives himself, that "people may not believe him, that the information will only lead to mass hysteria," grants that they "may be true," and then argues that self-preservation drives him. Victor is "truly worried about his self perception," so his silence protects his reputation at Justine's expense. The paragraph ends by assigning responsibility plainly with "he had the control to let her live." Granting a point and then pushing past it is real commentary on character.
The creature paragraph extends the same reading to a second secret. Victor hides his creation out of concern for "what people may think about him and his reputation," and the writer traces the creature's "deep rage" back to that neglect. The deathbed paragraph then catches a contradiction. Victor finally speaks and warns Walton about ambition, yet his plea for Walton "to continue chasing the monster" shows, in the essay's words, that his "yearn for vengeance is still incomplete." Across three body paragraphs the essay keeps returning to one cause, Victor's fear for himself, and that is what holds the line of reasoning together.
For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.
What Could Be Improved
The essay describes key moments without quoting them. The Justine paragraph says Victor fears people will think "he's a madman" but never quotes Victor saying so, and the creature paragraph covers the creature's grief without a line from his own account. One quotation in each, followed by a sentence on its wording, would make the commentary concrete.
The deathbed irony is the essay's best idea, and it shows up only at the end. The sentence "This is highly ironic as when Victor finally reveals his secret his words become of use and benefit others" could anchor the whole argument if the earlier paragraphs pointed toward it. A contradiction in Victor traced from the trial to his death is the kind of thread the sophistication point asks for. The introduction also brings up ambition and hubris and then drops them, so the essay never says how secrecy changes the novel's warning about ambition.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Literature essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lit literary argument essay



