3/6 AP English Literature Literary Argument Essay: Jane Eyre
This is a real literary argument essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 3/6 by our AI grader — one of many AP English Literature essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
choose a novel or play (must be jane eyre) in which a character struggles to balance personal independence with the desire for love or belonging. Then, in a well written essy, analyze how the character's complex struggle contributes to an interpretation of the work as a whole. Do not merely summarize the plot
The Essay
Many want the desire for love, but still want a feeling of independence. In Charlotte Bronte’s fiction, Jane Eyre, Jane Eyre balances the two by putting herself first before ever seeking a romantic partner, which in the Victorian era was seen as radical. Jane’s struggle at Gateshead, Lowood, and meeting Mr. Rochester all built her from being fearful and timid to being independent and enjoying her peace, while still having care for others. Jane’s complex character development shows one should choose himself or herself before seeking love, even if it’s not romantic. At Gateshead hall, Jane is abused physically and psychologically. Mrs. Reed and her children always put a class system to remind her that she came from nothing and was forced to be grateful for the abusive treatment she was given. In the red room, Jane is terrified. Not only can she not leave, but Jane is put through patriarchal abuse she never asked for. This abuse shapes Jane and allows her to realize that she was destined for more. Standing up for herself against Mrs. Reed begins to shape Jane's character throughout the novel.Even though Mrs. Reed or any of her children weren’t Jane’s romantic interest, Jane put herself first. This first stance of defiance against abuse communicates to the audience how a person doesn’t have to stand for abuse to find belonging and love. Once Jane begins to go to school, she is faced with hate from Mr. Brocklehurst. Before even going to school, at Gateshead, Mr. Brocklehurst comprises religion to force Jane to read more than just psalm. At Lowood, Mr. Brocklehurst defames Jane and calls her a liar. This use of religious abuse and hate from Mr. Brocklehurst makes Jane feel as if she is back at Gateshead in the red room, struggling to find that independence she once gained. Jane overcomes this obstacle through meeting a friend named Helen. Helen teaches Jane the right to introduce someone to faith. She tells her about Chrisitanity in a way that is nice and not condemning. Even though Jane wasn’t religious herself, Jane was given the independence to think about what Helen and Mr. Brocklehurst says and makes them her own truth. Jane’s triumph from religious psychosis to true understanding of religion shows that one act of kindness can deter all religious hate. Once meeting Mr. Rochester, eventually, he and Jane fall in love. At the wedding, she realized that he is still married. Jane chooses to run away and keep her autonomy. She would rather never see him again than to be a man’s mistress. While Jane is with her cousins, she chooses love and goes back to Mr. Rochester. Jane chose herself over the treatment that she was given and only then on her own terms did she go back. From Gateshead to Lowood, to meeting and reuniting with Mr. Rochester, Jane is independent and chooses love that will fill her make her happy, not to make her suffer.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Evidence & Commentary (2/4)
Sophistication (0/1)
What This Essay Gets Right
The thesis makes a real claim about the novel. The writer argues that Jane "balances the two by putting herself first before ever seeking a romantic partner, which in the Victorian era was seen as radical." Naming the era gives the claim stakes, and the next sentence lays out a clear plan, tracing Jane through "Gateshead, Lowood, and meeting Mr. Rochester."
That plan holds. Each body paragraph covers one stage of Jane's life and ends by connecting it back to her independence. The Gateshead paragraph closes on the idea that "a person doesn't have to stand for abuse to find belonging and love," and the Rochester paragraph names the key choice, that Jane "would rather never see him again than to be a man's mistress." The structure is easy to follow, and the thesis is defensible.
What Went Wrong (And How to Avoid It)
Most of the body retells events and then restates the thesis. The red room passage says Jane "is put through patriarchal abuse she never asked for" but never explains what the scene shows about her need for independence, and no paragraph quotes the novel. The Lowood paragraph has the most promising material, Helen's gentle faith set against Brocklehurst calling Jane a liar, but it jumps to "Jane's triumph from religious psychosis to true understanding of religion" without showing what Jane learns from Helen or how it shapes her later choices.
The ending also skips the hardest question the essay raises. Jane leaves Rochester to keep her autonomy and later "chooses love and goes back," and the essay never asks whether that return fulfills her independence or limits it. A full paragraph on that tension would deepen the commentary and reach toward the sophistication point. Word slips such as "comprises religion" in the Brocklehurst sentence also blur the meaning in places.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP English Literature essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write the AP Lit literary argument essay



