6/6 AP United States History LEQ Essay: Border disputes, 1844-1877
This is a real LEQ essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 6/6 by FRQuick's free AI LEQ grader. It is one of many AP United States History essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
Evaluate the extent in which the United States changed how it handled its border disputes in the period between 1844 and 1877
The Essay
The United States was recently defining its own national identity within the broader American culture of the early-to-mid 19th century, becoming more militaristic and developing a stronger set of ideals regarding expansion. America had been more peaceful with countries before this time period, with the government even agreeing to collaborate with other nations such as Britain in the Oregon Country. America had successfully dealt with other European Powers via the purchase of Florida from Spain and the Louisiana Purchase from Napoleon. However, life on the borders of America wasn’t simply peaceful and calm. Expansionist dogma, which was weeding its way throughout White American society, led to the Trail of Tears, which aggressively disrupted and destroyed the already damaged Native American life. Americans began believing they were ordained by God to take North America and govern it as they saw fit, whilst others were becoming disillusioned with the idea that America and Britain had to share Oregon Country. As the 19th century progressed, quite a few Americans pressured the government to annex the land completely to American power. Despite the argument that border disputes in the period between 1844 and 1877 generally remained diplomatic and calm, such as the purchase of Alaska from Russia or the Gadsden Purchase, the mid-19th century took a sharp turn and instead became plagued by unrest over the Mexican-American War and the Fenian Raids, showcasing the border instability and struggle deeply ingrained in American 19th-century government. The American government had recently had a major conflict with Mexico in Texas, where Americans had revolted and annexed it after Mexico promised to peacefully welcome American settlers under Mexican authority. Mexico was perceivably bitter about this slight to them; so when America had proposed to attempt to purchase California from them for an expensive fifteen million dollars, Mexico undoubtedly rejected the buyout. The newly elected President Polk was anxious and impatient for the start of a new war, so he purposely and aggressively confronted Mexico and fought against them on what Polk declared American soil. This new aggression after Polk’s nomination as president confirms America’s new trajectory to become ambitiously hostile. Before this war, America was generally careful with its relations with bordering countries, uncertain to start new conflicts while young and scrappy; however, Polk aggravating Mexico established that America was now growing dangerously audacious. Many Americans, however, did not necessarily agree with Polk’s mindset, triggered by Manifest Destiny; some even believed that Polk was a hawk desperate for war. Whigs and Lincoln himself criticized Polk’s claim that blood was shed, asking just where exactly on American soil this incident occurred. However, criticism of Polk was very weak, and America continued in its conflicts with Mexico, showing that even though some arguments stood against the War, the general public or government did little to stop this aggression. While conflicts played out in the South, in the North of the border there were key disputes from Irish-American citizens that displayed new aggressive behaviors. Many Irish immigrants flocked to America during the mid-19th century, caused mainly by the Potato Famine. The famine was responsible for the killing and displacement of millions of Irish citizens, creating a mass diaspora in America. Many Irish immigrants and their families still resented Britain; eventually storming British controlled Canada as the Fenian Brotherhood and attempting to seize land to pressure Britain into accepting Irish independence. While unsuccessful, these raids left a lasting impression on both Britain and America. America had unofficially met and formed relations with the Fenians, using the Fenians as a way to pressure the Canadian border without lasting diplomatic repercussions from Britain. The American government had intentionally sold thousands of weapons and artillery to the Brotherhood, knowing exactly where they would go and what they would be used for. The Fenian Raids directly display America’s intentional targeting of borders for its own gain instead of peaceful domestic dealings. The Raids allowed America to turn its head while keeping constant pressure on its foreign neighbors, something that was not a common occurrence in the early 19th century. Both the Fenian Raids and the Mexican War were two new American led or inspired actions that represent the new aggressive change in American foreign and border policy. Despite the new hostile characteristics of America, there is a strong argument that the border scene was actually heavily unchanged. This argument is typically supported by diplomatic conventions taken by the American Government, such as the purchase of Alaska from Russia to America. America saw the potential of Alaska’s timber and fishing industry, along with the advantage of taking away quality Northern land from Britain, and decided to make the purchase from Russia. Russia and America shared a common enemy that allowed for the indulgent purchase to run smoothly, both disliking Britain and their expansion into Canada. America and Russia’s deal supports the continuation of a peaceful America, yet doesn’t fully explain the new aggressive policy that dictated this purchase. America was still spiraling with a crazed fascination of Manifest Destiny, something that inspired their want to take Alaska and expand their territory. This cheap purchase promised more land in the hands of America, and promised them their supposed divine right to control more and more areas in Northern America. The argument continues; if America was so politically hostile on its borders, then what about the Gadsden purchase, which promised purchased land peacefully to America? But this agreement wasn’t all pleasant, it was lobbied vicariously by Southern Democrats who threatened Mexico with force to take the land. Mexico’s current leader was troubled by surviving debts from the war against America, and desperately needed the ten million they would gain from the selling of the land. The belligerent threats from American politicians does not set the scene of a respectful buy out from two countries who used diplomatic tranquility to establish deals; instead it paints America as an aggressive bully thirsting to still its need to accomplish the goals set by Manifest Destiny. The examples of America being diplomatically soft and peaceful through the Alaskan and Gadsden purchases are historically incorrect; America was undoubtedly hostile and used their ideology of Northern American control to fuel their interest in these purchases. America was not harmonious during the mid 19th century, despite arguments that the Alaskan and Gadsden purchases were key examples of such an idea. It was aggressively audacious and staunch on ideological grounds of controlling most North American land. These vicarious actions installed by American power eventually slowed on the American frontier as the world began focusing on overseas control and conflict, as developed through the Spanish-American war or the acquisition of foreign territory such as Puerto Rico or Hawaii into the vast and growing American Empire. The western frontier eventually closed during the late 19th century as America established its borders that still exist in the modern age.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Contextualization (1/1)
Evidence (2/2)
Analysis & Reasoning (2/2)
Why This Essay Scored Well
The introduction sets up what "changed" is measured against. The writer recalls the purchase of Florida from Spain, the Louisiana Purchase and the agreement to share "the Oregon Country" with Britain, so the period's wars read as a break from an earlier habit of making deals. The thesis then names evidence on both sides. It grants that some border questions stayed "diplomatic and calm, such as the purchase of Alaska from Russia or the Gadsden Purchase," and argues that the era "took a sharp turn" with the Mexican-American War and the Fenian Raids. That one sentence lays out the whole essay.
The first body paragraph builds the case for change in two regions. In the South, the writer traces the Mexican War from the annexation of Texas to Polk's claim that fighting began on American soil, and brings in the Whigs and Lincoln asking "just where exactly on American soil this incident occurred." The paragraph then moves north to the Fenian Raids and ties them to the Potato Famine and Irish resentment of Britain. Both halves close on the same claim, that these were "new American led or inspired actions," so the evidence adds up to one argument.
The complexity point works differently from the others, because it comes from one move in the second body paragraph. The writer takes the two strongest examples against the thesis and argues that each one fits it anyway. The Alaska deal was driven by Manifest Destiny and a wish to take "quality Northern land from Britain." The Gadsden Purchase looks peaceful, but the writer points to Mexico's war debts and threats from Southern Democrats and concludes that the deal "paints America as an aggressive bully." Answering the counterargument on its own evidence is what earns the point.
For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.
What Could Be Improved
Some evidence in the Fenian section goes further than the record supports. The essay says the government sold weapons to the Brotherhood "knowing exactly where they would go and what they would be used for." Fenians did buy surplus Civil War arms, but the federal government issued a neutrality proclamation in 1866 and seized Fenian weapons at the border. An argument about American tolerance of the raids would be easier to defend. The California figure is also off. Fifteen million dollars is what the treaty ending the war paid, and the offer made before the war was as much as $25 million for California and New Mexico.
The essay also leaves out the clearest border settlement inside its own dates. It mentions sharing "the Oregon Country" with Britain but never brings up the 1846 treaty that divided it peacefully. Taking on that example in the counterargument paragraph would make the rebuttal harder to doubt. Word slips such as "lobbied vicariously" (probably "vigorously") are worth a proofread.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP United States History LEQ free with AI, or open the APUSH essay grader.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write an LEQ



