6/6 AP World History LEQ Essay: Ottoman and Qing rule
This is a real leq essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 6/6 by our AI grader — one of many AP World History essay examples in our library.
The Prompt
In the period circa 1200 to 1800 empires around the world used various political, social, and economic policies to maintain power.
Explain how the methods empires used to maintain power shaped social, gender, or family structures in the period 1200 to 1800.
Your response may focus on any example(s) of imperial policy in the period circa 1200 to 1800. You are not expected to address the entire time period in your response.
The Essay
The Ottoman Empire expanded into the Balkans and the Qing Empire extended rule into Inner Asia. After gaining new territories, both empires had to decide how to govern communities that already had their own religious practices and culture. Both empires relied on people from the territories they controlled, but they shaped social hierarchies in different ways. The Ottomans maintained power by forcing Christian boys from the Ottoman-controlled areas to be recruited for service, but this gave some of them a way to gain power and status. The Qing used existing local elites in the new territories which helped those leaders keep their own culture and some authority. The Ottoman devshirme system gave the sultan a way to build a military and government that was made up of people trained to serve him. Ottoman officials took Christian boys from their communities, converted them to Islam, and trained them for bureaucratic and military positions. Some of the boys became Janissaries, elite military soldiers who were loyal to the sultan, which gave them great political power and greatly contributed to the Ottomans’ military power. For some, imperial service gave them a level of status they wouldn’t have had otherwise. However, this method still depended on separating boys from their families and religious communities and reforming them into Turkish-speaking Muslims. The Qing Dynasty’s rapid expansion led to administrative demands that needed something better than their bureaucratic system they had used for hundreds of years. The Qing Court of Colonial Affairs was created, helping govern territories like Tibet and Outer Mongolia. The Qing officials relied on local elites to handle the daily tasks, while the Court of Colonial Affairs handled things like trade, economic affairs, religion, and the cultural aspects of these territories. This helped the Qing extend their control through these elites while allowing them to keep some of their own authority. Both empires used people from the populations they governed to maintain control. The Ottomans recruited boys taken away from their own religious communities and culture, but gave them a new way to rise in social status through imperial service, while the Qing policy reinforced parts of a social hierarchy that already existed, going to great lengths to make sure the people of these territories could keep their own culture. The Qing strengthened their control by letting local leaders keep some authority over day-to-day tasks. The Ottomans strengthened the sultan’s military and government through assimilating the Christian boys into Muslim culture, training them for imperial service through the devshirme system, giving them a path to higher power and status.
Score Breakdown
Thesis (1/1)
Contextualization (1/1)
Evidence (2/2)
Analysis & Reasoning (2/2)
Why This Essay Scored Well
The introduction gives context before the argument. It places the Ottomans in the Balkans and the Qing in Inner Asia, then names the problem both faced, governing communities "that already had their own religious practices and culture." The thesis follows with a method and a social effect for each empire. Ottoman recruitment of Christian boys gave some of them "a way to gain power and status," and the Qing use of local elites let those leaders keep "their own culture and some authority."
The evidence is specific on both sides. The devshirme paragraph traces boys from conversion through training to the Janissaries, "elite military soldiers who were loyal to the sultan." The Qing paragraph names the Court of Colonial Affairs, places it in Tibet and Outer Mongolia, and splits the work between local elites who handled daily tasks and the court that handled trade, religion and culture.
The complexity comes from one turn in the devshirme paragraph. After showing that imperial service raised some boys' status, the writer adds that the system still depended on "separating boys from their families and religious communities." The same policy opened a path upward and broke up families, which speaks directly to the prompt's mention of family structures. The closing sentences then set the two empires side by side, with Ottoman recruitment creating new status and Qing policy reinforcing "parts of a social hierarchy that already existed."
For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.
What Could Be Improved
The Qing paragraph describes the policy and stops. It says local elites could keep "some of their own authority" but never explains how that held an older social order in place, or who stayed on top of it. The devshirme paragraph explains its mechanism in full, so the comparison is lopsided.
The essay has no separate conclusion. The comparison starts midway through the Qing paragraph with "Both empires used people from the populations they governed," which blurs evidence and argument together. A few details are loose too. The Court of Colonial Affairs, or Lifan Yuan, was set up in 1638, before the Qing took Beijing, so it came ahead of the expansion the essay says produced it. The claim that the Qing had used their bureaucratic system "for hundreds of years" also needs care, since the dynasty inherited that system from the Ming.
Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP World History essay free with AI.
Want the method behind this essay? How to write an AP LEQ



