FRQuick

6/7 AP United States History DBQ Essay Example #7

This is a real DBQ essay written by an AP student (personal details removed) and scored 6/7 by FRQuick's free AI DBQ grader. It is one of many AP United States History essay examples in our library.

The Prompt

1. Evaluate the extent to which the institution of slavery shaped United States society between 1783 and 1840.

The Essay

After the American Revolution, the United States was built on ideas of freedom and equality. However, slavery continued, especially in the South, creating disagreements throughout the country. As the nation expanded, debates over slavery became more serious. Between 1783 and 1840, slavery greatly shaped American society by influencing politics, religion, and the economy while increasing tensions between those who supported slavery and those who wanted it abolished. After the Revolution, many Americans began questioning whether slavery went against the nation's founding beliefs. Document 1 states that slavery contradicts the Massachusetts Constitution because all people are born free and equal. This demonstrates how slavery created conflict between American beliefs and the treatment of African Americans. Given that William Cushing was the chief justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Court, his perspective was influenced by his responsibility to uphold the state Constitution. Similarly, Document 2 expresses how Thomas Jefferson's support of slavery contradicted his belief that all men were created equal. This reveals the inequality in American society. As a free African American, Benjamin Banneker wrote to Jefferson to challenge his support of slavery and remind him of his own words about freedom. Together, these documents show how slavery challenged America's founding principles and encouraged people to question racial inequality. Slavery also created political and religious disagreements that threatened national unity. Document 3 states that the debate over Missouri threatened to divide the country. This shows how slavery created tension between free and slave states. In the context of the Missouri Compromise of 1820, Missouri entered as a slave state while Maine entered as a free state. The agreement also banned slavery in much of the remaining Louisiana Territory north of the 36°30′ line. This demonstrates how the government struggled to maintain political balance because of disagreements over slavery. Mathew Carey feared these disagreements could destroy national unity. Document 4 argues that slavery was acceptable because the Bible supported it. This demonstrates how some Americans used religion to defend slavery. Given that Richard Furman was a Baptist leader in South Carolina, his perspective was influenced by the importance of slavery in Southern society. Together, these documents show how slavery influenced both political decisions and religious beliefs. Slavery also influenced the economy and encouraged the growth of abolitionist movements. Document 5 exposes how Northern businessmen profited from transporting enslaved people to the South. This demonstrates that slavery benefited people in both the North and South. As an antislavery activist, William Lloyd Garrison wanted to expose Northern involvement in the slave trade. In contrast, Document 6 expresses that all people are children of God and that no one should own another person. This shows how slavery encouraged people to fight for freedom and equality. As an African American preacher, Jarena Lee believed Christianity supported abolition and joined the American Anti-Slavery Society. These documents show how economic interests helped slavery continue while religious and social movements worked to end it. Finally, Document 7 shows how enslaved people could still be treated as property when brought into New York, even though it was a free state. This demonstrates that slavery continued to influence laws outside the South. The American Anti-Slavery Almanac created this image to criticize laws that protected enslavers instead of enslaved people. This reveals the contradiction between Northern beliefs in freedom and the laws that still protected slavery. In conclusion, slavery greatly shaped American society between 1783 and 1840 by influencing politics, religion, and the economy. Although abolitionists worked to promote freedom and equality, people who supported slavery continued to have strong political and economic influence, especially in the South. By 1840, slavery supporters still had greater control over the institution itself, but abolitionists had helped grow opposition and bring attention to the injustice of slavery. This shows that both sides shaped American society, but their disagreements continued to divide the country and threaten its unity.

Score Breakdown

Thesis (1/1)

Contextualization (1/1)

Evidence from Documents (2/2)

Evidence Beyond Documents (1/1)

Sourcing (1/1)

Complexity (0/1)

Why This Essay Scored Well

The thesis names three areas slavery shaped (politics, religion, and the economy) and a growing tension "between those who supported slavery and those who wanted it abolished." The body paragraphs take those areas in order. The conclusion adds an extent judgment, arguing that "By 1840, slavery supporters still had greater control over the institution itself" while abolitionists built opposition.

All seven documents serve the argument. The first body paragraph uses Cushing's ruling and Banneker's letter to Jefferson to show that "slavery challenged America's founding principles." The third pairs Garrison's exposé of Northern slave traders with Jarena Lee's religious case against slavery, concluding that "economic interests helped slavery continue while religious and social movements worked to end it."

The Missouri Compromise passage carries the outside evidence. The writer explains that Missouri entered as a slave state, Maine entered as a free state, and slavery was banned north of the 36°30′ line, then ties those terms to the claim that "the government struggled to maintain political balance."

Sourcing connects each author's position to the argument. Cushing's view was shaped by "his responsibility to uphold the state Constitution," and Furman's defense of slavery is read through his role as "a Baptist leader in South Carolina".

For the full point-by-point rubric behind this score, read our AP essay rubric breakdown.

What Could Be Improved

The lost point is complexity. Each body paragraph treats one theme and closes with a summary of what the documents show, so the essay lists the ways slavery shaped society without weighing them or tracing change from 1783 to 1840. The writer's own reading of Document 7, that it "reveals the contradiction between Northern beliefs in freedom and the laws that still protected slavery," could anchor a sustained argument. Read alongside Document 5's Northern slave traders, it shows the free states were tied to slavery too, and following that thread across the whole period would earn the point.

Document 6 gets thinner sourcing than the others. Jarena Lee is identified as "an African American preacher," but the essay never explains how her faith shaped the argument that "no one should own another person." The sourcing point is already earned, so this is polish, but one sentence on that link would match the care given to Cushing and Furman.

Ready to improve your own essay? Grade your AP United States History DBQ free with AI, or open the APUSH essay grader.

Want the method behind this essay? How to write a DBQ

Related Essays